Click here to go to the Home Page for www.WalkSanDiego.org Walk San Diego - Promoting Walkable Communities

 
WalkSanDiego Editor's note: This approach is so far recommended only for rural areas.
Making Driving Seem More Dangerous Could Make It Safer

The December 7th issue of Wired magazine featured an interesting article titled "Roads Gone Wild" by Tom McNichol. The article is about a new kind of traffic engineering advocated by Holland's Hans Monderman. The article lead in starts:

No street signs. No crosswalks. No accidents.
Surprise: making driving seem more dangerous could make it safer

Another graphic has the title: How to Build a Better Intersection: Chaos = Cooperation

Some interesting quotes:

* Hans Monderman is a traffic engineer who hates traffic signs. ...To him, they are an admission of failure, a sign - literally - that a road designer somewhere hasn't done his job. The trouble with traffic engineers is that when there's a problem with a road, they always try to add something. To my mind it's much better to remove things.

* Monderman ripped out all the traditional instruments used by traffic engineers to influence driver behavior - traffic lights, road markings, and some pedestrian crossings - and in their place created a traffic circle. The circle is remarkable for what it doesn't contain: signs or signals telling drivers how fast to go, or curbs separating the street and sidewalk, so it's unclear exactly where the car zone ands and the pedestrian zone begins. To an approaching driver the intersection is utterly ambiguous - and that's the point.

* The drivers slow to gauge the intentions of crossing bicyclists and walkers. Negotiations over right-of-way are made through fleeting eye contact. Remarkably, traffic flows smoothly.

* Experts call it psychological traffic calming.

* I think the future of transportation in our cities is slowing down the roads. When you try to speed things up, the system tends to fail, and then you are stuck with a design that moves traffic inefficiently and is hostile to pedestrians and human exchange.

* The way you build a road affects far more than the movement of vehicles. It determines how drivers behave on it.

* The central premise guiding American road design was that driving and walking were utterly incompatible modes of transport and the should be segregated as much as possible.

* Traffic engineers viewed vehicle movement the same way a hydraulics engineer approaches water moving through a pipe - to increase flow make the pipe fatter. Roads signs rather than road architecture became the chief way to enforce behavior.

* The strict segregation of cars and people turned out to have unintended consequences on towns and cities.

Monderman's Recipe:

Step 1: Remove Signs - The architecture of the road, not signs and signals dictates traffic flow.

Step 2: Install Art - The height of the fountain indicates how congested the interstate is.

Step 3: Share the Spotlight - Lights illuminate not only the roadbed, but also the pedestrian areas.

Step 4: Do it in the Road - Cafes extend to the edge of the street, further emphasizing the idea of shared space.

Step 5: See Eye to Eye - Right-of-way is negotiated by human interaction rather than commonly ignored signs.

Step 6: Eliminate Curbs - Instead of a raised curb, sidewalks are denoted by texture and color.

Monderman says this prescription applies to rural areas, and may not work in urban areas. Still, some aspects could be expected to work almost anywhere that pedestrians, bikes, and vehicles mix.

 
<< back to top >>